Why You Should Thin The Carrots In Your Garden – Or Not!


Carrot Couple

Carrots are people too… Earlier this spring, I planted a variety of heirloom red carrots by seed, then waited for them to germinate.  When I checked on the young seedlings, I knew they were spaced too close together and should probably be thinned.  Carrots need space to develop into the tall straight specimens we see at the market.  Carrot seeds are almost always seeded too close together, because they are so tiny. Thinning is recommended for the first time when the plants are 4 inches tall. Remove the smallest and scrawniest plants or those that are growing right on top of one another. Ideally the plants are thinned to about a thumb’s-width apart. The carrots can also be thinned again about a month later to about 1 1/2 to 2 inches apart.  By then the ‘thinned’ carrots should be large enough to eat as baby carrots.  Click HERE for more tips on planting and thinning carrots.  Obviously, you can see by my lovely carrot couple that I did not do the whole thinning thing.  I would make a terrible farmer.  I have always had a problem being ‘The Decider’ and choosing which plants get to stay and which get pulled out to only become chicken scraps, so I decided to leave them alone and see what happened.  Well, when I pulled a jumbled mass of carrots out of the ground the other day, I wasn’t so sure, but then – magic!  I know that the technical term for them is really ‘Ugly Vegetables’ but I have had so much fun with them.  They have so much personality!  Meet the rest of my carrot people:

Dancing Carrots


Cool Dude with Rad Hair and Long Earrings


Carrot Love


More Carrot Love


Carrot Family


Carrot Gang


Carrot Snake Impersonaters


Another Photo of My Happy Couple


Interesting Characters AKA Ugly Vegetables

I love my carrot people, but you get to be The Decider in your garden. For those of you that have personality carrots, send me photos!  For more information on proper carrot growing, here are a few more good sources:





5 thoughts on “Why You Should Thin The Carrots In Your Garden – Or Not!

  1. Reblogged this on goodmotherdiet and commented:

    I’ve been working like crazy in my vegetable garden, feeling late but after so much rain and my trip to India, well it is what it is. I have fond memories of my first carrot year. I’m reposting for all of you who may be planting carrots this year. Enjoy your carrot people!


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s